Severus Snape had a frightfully miserable childhood, that much I will admit. And that must have been hard on him – living in such a low-life area, being constantly bullied by his peers, having to return every summer to a place that he hated passionately, and being rejected by a girl he liked.
But that sound quite familiar, doesn’t it?
Oh, right, that’s because Mr. Harry Potter went through exactly the same thing. Except Harry also had the pressure of saving the entire world from downfall and he had to deal with pesky reporters (cough, Rita Skeeter, cough) as well the public mistrusting him and the government turning against him. But all that harry did was have a few emotional outbursts when it became too much. He remained a good person inside despite so much manipulation, and that’s what matters.
Snape? Well, he decided to join a group of racist extremists intent on murdering an entire race of people whom they considered impure. And this is dealing with half the amount of stress that Harry did.
Now, many people will justify his actions by saying, “He was in love with Lily! He had his heart broken! You can’t blame him!” But I don’t agree one bit. Both Severus Snape and James Potter were in love with Lily Evans and she rejected both of them. James responded by becoming a genuinely better person and stopped bullying people unnecessarily, because that was the reason that Lily rejected him. Snape, on the other hand, decided it would be fun to start murdering all other people like her.
Furthermore, in high school, Snape had an ongoing rivalry with the Marauders (James, Remus, Sirius, and Peter). This was the sort of rivalry that many people have in high school, so you wouldn’t assume that it would become such a big deal. But they both allowed it to. Since Severus was a Death Eater (a follower of Voldemort) he knew that Peter Pettigrew was a traitor to the Order of the Phoenix. But when Sirius Black was unfairly convicted and sent to prison for twelve years, he did nothing to stop it, despite being aware of the fact that he was innocent. He could easily have testified and saved an innocent man from twelve years of torture, but chose not to, simply because of a high school rivalry.
Snape also bullied children. Children, who were excited to learn potions for the first time. And these children, who were supposed to be able to look up to these teachers as mentors, were terrified of him.
I’m sure we all remember that scene, from The Prisoner of Azkaban, where Remus brings the third years a boggart to fight for their Defense Against the Dark Arts class. And how Neville’s greatest fear is Professor Snape, and he makes him wear his grandmother’s clothes? Hilarious, it really was. But Neville Longbottom, a boy whose parents are going to forever be in a mental hospital because they’ve been tortured to insanity – his greatest fear is his Chemistry teacher?
I mean, imagine being that terrified of someone who is supposed to teach you, to mentor you, to guide you, to be your guru – whatever you want to call it.
And when handing out detentions to Neville, Severus was intent on making his life a living hell. In the Order of the Phoenix, he made Neville disembowel toads as a punishment for being late to class, knowing full well that he had a pet toad.
Poor Neville. Snape really did have it out for him, didn’t he? And I don’t think that having the love of your life die is an excuse to make other people live through the same pain that you did. Especially innocent children.
Many people may say, “He became good at the end! That means he is a good person!” Well, let me just clarify that, honey, because you’re not taking the prophecy into account.
The prophecy stated that the one to bring the dark lord’s downfall would be “Born to those who have thrice defied him, born as the seventh month dies”. This could have applied to either Harry Potter or Neville Longbottom. Tom Riddle (Lord Voldemort) chose Harry to be his opponent, and this is the reason that Snape betrayed him – because he didn’t want his master to kill the woman he loved. However, if Voldemort had chosen Neville, Severus Snape would have lived and died as the most loyal Death Eater who ever lived.
I get that Severus’ childhood could not have been easy. But do you really think that a bit of bullying and a teenage ‘lost love’ is an excuse for treating everyone else in your life so abominably? Because I sure don’t.